Rimmel Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer Pencil — Earl Grey (264), Highly Pigmented Long-Wear with Built-In Smudger

Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer in 264 Earl Grey is a highly pigmented, long-lasting pencil eyeliner with a built-in smudger and sharpener for precise, smudgeable eye looks.

Whether you want a crisp, defined line or a soft, smoky edge, this pencil balances intense color and easy blending in a compact design. The creamy formula glides on smoothly, sets to a water-resistant finish, and is made to hold through a busy day or a night out. Its built-in smudger allows quick diffusion along lash lines while the integrated sharpener keeps the tip fine for detailed work—no extra tools required.

How does the formula perform during everyday wear?

The formulation focuses on rich color payoff with a waterproof finish that resists fading and transfer. It establishes a clear line quickly yet offers a short window to soften before it sets, making it practical for both precision and smoky looks.

• Highly pigmented core for one-stroke color payoff.
• Water-resistant finish that minimizes smudging and running.
• Sets quickly for lasting wear throughout the day.
• Suitable for top and bottom lash lines without heavy flaking.

Can I create different eye looks with this pencil?

Yes—the combination of a creamy glide and a handy smudger makes the pencil versatile for sharp liner, soft edges, or blended smoky effects. Adjust pressure and use the smudger to diffuse or keep lines clean for different styles.

• Light pressure for a soft, diffused shadow along the lash line.
• Firm pressure for a defined, graphic line with even pigment.
• Use the smudger tip to soften harsh edges or to create a smoky wing.
• Built-in sharpener keeps the point fine for tightlining and detail work.

How convenient is it for travel and touch-ups?

Compact and multi-functional, this pencil was designed with portability in mind. Because it combines pencil, smudger, and sharpener in one, it reduces what you need to carry for on-the-go fixes or quick changes between daytime and evening looks.

• Small size fits easily in makeup bags, pockets, or clutch purses.
• All-in-one tool eliminates the need for separate brushes or sharpeners.
• Quick smudging option for fast daytime softening or evening drama.
• Durable waterproof formula minimizes the need for frequent reapplication.

What shade is Earl Grey and who does it flatter?

Earl Grey is a deep, cool-toned gray that provides a softer alternative to black while still delivering definition. It enhances natural lash lines and works well across many eye colors and skin tones for a modern, understated look.

• Cool gray hue for smoky, contemporary definition without stark contrast.
• Compliments blue, green, hazel, and brown eyes by intensifying contrast subtly.
• Ideal for daytime sophistication or layered for nighttime drama.
• Suits neutral to cool skin undertones especially well, but is versatile overall.

Who is this for: This pencil suits anyone who wants a reliable, travel-friendly eyeliner that offers bold pigment and shaping flexibility. It’s a practical pick for beginners who appreciate an all-in-one applicator with minimal tools, as well as experienced users who need a dependable, long-wear pencil for precision work, smoky effects, or quick touch-ups on the move.